Realities vis a vis Biases

It is known to my readers that i had decided to quit the pen (much to the chagrin of Sukhi) because i was of the opinion my purpose of writing was dead. Fate, if it exists, had other plans for me. As is known to many, i am a politically outspoken person and keep tweeting about political developments in my home state of West Bengal. And by virtue of being connected, they get posted to Facebook too. As a comment to one of my posts on Facebook a friend of mine  commented about Jyoti Basu, which led to a series of comments and counter comments. AT this point it would be opportune to declare that this friend of mine is anti Mamata Bannerjee for personal biases of which only she has knowledge of. So much so she seems to have lost her rationale thoughts.

Being politically ignorant is no crime. I do not claim to be aware of all happenings in this country either. But i do try to read up and support my ideas with facts. What outraged me was Rituparna’s claim that the “Education system” and “administration” under Left rule was worth appreciating and “Railways was under 2000 crore debt to government”. God bless her. I seriously wish to know where she got her facts from.

All i would like to state in this post are some facts i read up o the internet after reading her hilariously pathetic comment.

1. The Indian Railways as on July 2010 had a turnover of 2.13 trillion USD and made a profit of 1328 crore in fiscal year 2009-2010. Not only is the Railways on the positive side of the spectrum, it has already planned to convene a meeting to discuss strategies to increase revenue to keep pace with rising inflation without hiking passenger fares. Development with a human face i would term that. Most recent news says that BHEL and SAIL have signed MoU with the Railways.

2. The goodwill of the administration of West Bengal is for the people to decide in 2011 assembly polls. The Netai carnage is just a tip of the iceberg on the incompetence of the administration. The butchering of villagers started at 9.20am in the morning while the police (P.S. located 3km away) took more than 12 hours to “walk” to the village. In their affidavit to the Court, the SP said they were convinced (without showing what drove them to the conclusion) calls from villagers were actually hoax calls from Maoists. A joint military offensive is in place in the state, but still the CPI-M has to maintain armed cadre camps (accepted by various leaders of the Communist Alliance). Says a lot about the competence of state administration. Why, have we forgotten Rizwanur incident when even the Commissioner of Police, Kolkata was “bought” by a rich businessman.

Is this the fate of all those who oppose CPI-M?

3. Mamata Bannerjee has always been touted anti industrialisation. I hope Rituparna has heard of Haldia Petrochemicals. It was brandished as “CPM’s showpiece industry”. The much celebrated Haldi Petrochemicals is in tatters now. So is Bakreswar Thermal Power Project. More than 66000 industries (as on the 25th year of Left Front in power) are locked out in Bengal thanks to the militant trade union wing CITU. Mamata simply demanded fair rehabilitation for land losers in Singur. With almost identical land lying (except that it was unfertile) on the other side of the Durgapur expressway it is a mystery why Tatas were adamant on taking the fertile land, and why the WB Land Reforms Dept had to make FALSE documents to show the land was actually unfertile. Why not mention Teat industry? What about tourism? Despite being blessed with such a great biodiversity the tourism industry has suffered in the state. Most tea estates in north Bengal locked out and sold to realtors for big budget housing projects (Chandmari for example. really CPI-M is “peoples government”).

3. Let us not even talk about the economy of Bengal. The Finance Minister of West Bengal recently borrowed 5000 crore from the market, although signals are rare that the debt can be cleared off. Populism in their initial years and nepotism thereafter harmed the state economy so much so that the official debt of West bengal is now about Rs 192000 crores. Central funds (most recently the NREGA) had to be returned because of non utilisation. The “government of the people” had to burden the people with a 1% hike in VAT to meet the debt. West Bengal is on the verge of bankruptcy.

4. Education. The less said the better. Having studied in a government college, the sorry state of education in this province lay bare in front of our eyes for three years. Most recently, district head of CPI-M in Jalpaiguri had been indicted for “recommending” “known” people for posts of primary teachers. This is rampant all over. Posts in most government institutions are filled with members of the “Coordination Committee”.

5. Health – Need i say anything? Would Rituparna go to SSKM hospital if she fell ill? Leave aside personal comments. When my grandmother met with a fatal accident in June 2010, the ward boy at a local hospital near Digha demanded Rs 100 or else he would not even touch the stretcher. This is nothing new. Such stories are heard everyday in almost every govt. hospital in West Bengal.

this is the place for patients

6. Employment – West Bengal is officially the most debt ridden state in India with the number of registered unemployed youths in this state amounting to 4.14 crore in 2004-2005 (the figure sadly hasn’t had a downward slope). With elections looming in the horizon, the West Bengal govt decided to put 66000 teachers position up for grabs. After more than a decade. What stopped them from doing the same before? And with the state of economy, may i ask how the government plans to pay the teachers?

Usual scene at a government office/university: No Work

7. Rituparna also accused that since i enjoyed the luxuries of a city life i would not understand the trials of a small town life, of how people there suffered because of “Mamata”. I wonder if she forgot that i was born and brought up in a small town called Jalpaiguri. And let me also remind her that the Indian National Congress is in power in my town for the third consecutive term and with every passing year the civic amenities are getting better. TMC is their ally in the municipality. And what “sufferings” is she referring to? Does she not have a TV to scream news of CITU or CPM’s choking traffic almost everyday under some pretext (despite being in power in the state).

Has she forgotten in the last two years NOT a SINGLE BANDH was called by TMC. Instead the CPM, BJP and INC had troubled people of Bengal with strikes at the slightest of reasons. Right from Marichjhapi in 1979 to Keshpur in 2000, Dalgaon in 2003, Nandigram in 2007, it is the Marxist party which has violated human rights and killed people. Any such incident about TMC? I am all ears!

8. The present unrest in North Bengal was created by none other than the Left. Subhash Ghishing and GNLF are their products. DGHC which introduced corruption in the hills was just a barter by the ruling govt back in 1987 to keep control on the hills and the votebank. Now that a rival faction GJM has assumed reigns, they put up a communal organisation “Bangla Bhasha Bachao Committee” which is no less violent than GJM to put whole of North Bengal into brink of civil war.

Same with naxalism. Born in 1970’s against the anti populist policies of then United Front govt, Maoists recieved patronage from CPI-M. (Remember Buddhadeb banned maoists in Bengal as late as 2009).

8. Let us come to the last point. About Jyoti Basu. Yes i have no qualms in saying that Jyoti Basu was the architect of the fall of Bengal. There can never be doubts about that. His policies since mid 1990’s (only to be aggravated by the arrogance of his successor) has brought Bengal to the brink of bankruptcy. The ban on English, computers left a full generation uneducated while bright minds left the state for “greener” pastures. The present CM of Bengal had himself quit Basu’s cabinet saying it was “chor cabinet” (only to rejoin as the prospect of becoming CM loomed large). The same Jyoti Basu and Buddhadeb Bhattacharya were indicted by Supreme court of India for irregularities in allotment of land in Salt Lake. Death can not rid him of the charges. History will question his leadership.

We all agree TMC is not the perfect alternative to CPI-M. It is not an alternative at all. But when history has given us the opportunity to rid ourselves of a government which has pushed a state to extinction for 34 years, we should use it fully.  Things cannot get any worse. We are at the bottom of an abysmal pit. And if TMC cannot live upto expectations we can throw them out of power 5 years hence. But if Left Front is allowed to come to power for 8th time, we shall never be take up the resolve to stand up against their (mis)rule. So let us give Mamata Bannerjee a chance. She is a woman with a lot of promise. A street fighter that she is, she is much closer to people than the leaders in Alimuddin. Their incompetence cannot be hidden in their mask of culture.

Its time we rose above personal biases and accepted the realities.

All figures stated in the blog post can be googled and obtained from websites of Central Government of India as well as State Government of West Bengal. They are also quoted from blogs and articles in the websites of various newspapers like The Hindu, Indian Express, Anandabazar Patrika, and Business Standard. This post has nothing to do with favouritism and is purely based on facts and observations. If people still choose to side with Communist Party of India (Marxist) i would term it as unfortunate for Bengal.


About Agnivo Niyogi

Typical Aantel, reader, blogger, news addict, opinionated. Digital media enthusiast. Didi fanboi. Joy Bangla!

Posted on January 18, 2011, in Politics and tagged , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink. 7 Comments.

  1. I dont know what to say. I read it in one breath. It was suffocating and while I read it, I felt what possibly those innocent people have gone through if mere reading about the reality is so uncomfortable.

    It is truly an amazing piece of writing.


  2. I am so glad you took to writing.. whatevere the reason.

    Personally I think it would have been better if u would not have taken the name of Rituparna. And i have often found even u blinded by ur “love” for Mamta.

    But I really like the way u end it all… “We all agree TMC is not the perfect alternative to CPI-M. It is not an alternative at all. But when history has given us the opportunity to rid ourselves of a government which has pushed a state to extinction for 34 years, we should use it fully. Things cannot get any worse. We are at the bottom of an abysmal pit. And if TMC cannot live upto expectations we can throw them out of power 5 years hence. But if Left Front is allowed to come to power for 8th time, we shall never be take up the resolve to stand up against their (mis)rule. So let us give Mamata Bannerjee a chance. She is a woman with a lot of promise. A street fighter that she is, she is much closer to people than the leaders in Alimuddin. Their incompetence cannot be hidden in their mask of culture.”

    Awesome… with such lines (and if u become her campaigner, u will surely make her win)


  3. Sometimes it becomes difficult to chose between sides but West Bengal is not that kind of state.


  4. Uncomfortable read but required.

    Keep writing.


  5. 1. very well written agni…
    2. readers…i am that rituparna whom he is referring now and then out of silent unsuppressable anger, forgetting the fact that he could have avoided this and how ppl wud take it when you bring ur frnz in limelight on grounds of political discussions.
    3. I wish I cud write a similar blog…but I dont want to sound “mamata-philic”.
    4. I have more sound grounds ….. I wud like 2 in vite agni in my resident in Rishra and show gim various fields from torturing slum ppl to mismanagemaent in railways….(I dont want a damn my train running in time??…thats my question…It is all the more delayed…n cancelled nowadays…thanks 2 mamata di..I dont wanna speak of sealdah line..Its more heinous)
    5. TMC ppl show off…. eg..Agnivo.
    Being a student of physiology he deliberately put up that dead body’s pic….Its a dead body agni…for God’s sake, dont advertise it.
    6…agni, i guess we studied comp since std 3…who was the govt. then?
    7. I regularly see TMC ppl behave arrogantly n other afraid of their “hitting” tendency…especially the ladies of ladies compartment…!!! Other passengers afraid of them leave them seats in fear of being bad-mouthed…..
    8. If so much was the miscreancy….how did the rule survive for 34 yrs/…..this very same ppl voted…right?…
    9. Breaking of furnitures in a representative house and setting fires in trains and creating bandhs during examinations…is one famous job of the less-educated mamata.
    *** 2007 chemistry ISC exam cancelled in WB coz mamata di organised some damn bandh…so sweet
    ***2006 I got down in the railway tracks between konnagar and hindmotor coz mamata di said…”stop transport”….I was to write my part exam that day at 2 pm…this occured at 11.30 in the morning…so cute of her…she is an angel…(Dont ask how I reached the hall)

    Lastly,….I am not a CPM supporter but today agni became a mamata -supporter more than a friend…. he cud have told this to me in personal and not here….. He is in the plan of doing PHd in bengal under mamata ‘s rule…Let us wish him luck coz he chose mamata…I will question him after 5 yrs….wot his views are…not now

    lots of luv,
    Ritu a.k.a Rituparna


  6. 1.Ritu get your facts right as i always say, first you said railways is on debt, when i proved its not you raise question if its running on time. Well sorry to inform you, Railways amenities is BETTER now compared to under LALU. Its not my saying, its OFFICIAL.

    2. I am not “TMC people” in case you do not know, i am a signed member of the Indian Youth Congress.

    3. Ritu you are quite sad at the pic of the dead body. Imagine the horror of the family of the man in the pic. It is from Lalgarh where CPM butchered innocent villagers. I almost puked after seeing this picture in the Indian Express. But the more gruesome the reality is, the easier to accept it.

    4. Ritu dont prove your idiocy again. CPIM banned computers in 1980s when Rajeev Gandhi introduced them. (plus computers as a subject in WB MADHYAMIK curriculum came in 1998). In case i am not wrong you studied ICSE curriculum.

    5. How do you know someone misbehaving in Ladies compartment is TMC? Do they have it stamped on their faces? Should i count you the list of women raped and murdered by the CPM in last 2 years? Heard of Tapasi Malik have you?

    6. The (mis) rule lasted for 34 years because THERE WAS NO OPPOSITION. It was divided. In case you go through the election results and vote share in the EC WEBSITE, Cong+TMC always got more vote% than CPM, but no of votes was always divided thats why CPM won, DIvide and rule. Simple. Plus rigging. Plus Nepotism. Plus politics of violence.

    7. I invite you to come with me and tour villages in North Bengal to see how CPM terrorises people so that no OPPOSITION candidate can file nominations even.

    8. The rising violence and anarchy in this state is just a manifestation of the ruling party’s fear of losing power. The Communist party is historically arrogant. And never ease out of power easily. Look around. Russia for example.

    9. Bandhs were intriduced in India by the CPM. It has a history of disrupting life. You cited two examples. i can cite many more. Bandhs have never helped anything and Mamata understood that. like i said, since 2008 there has been no Bandh on TMC’s part but CPM continues to do so.

    10. About TMC people brandishing power. Well i guess you do not have a para club of CPM in RIshra or else you would know what brandishing power is. Pujo time specially.

    11. I have also suffered because of bandhs and disruptions too. I could not goto AIIMS because of a Bandh by CPM. I could not come to Kolkata once for an exam because of a Bandh by TMC.

    12. In case you missed reading the last paragraph i support Mamata only because i want to give change a chance so that i have the option to compare the two parties and select the better option. And like i always say, if Mamata comes to power and commits the same mistakes the present is doing, i will always take up the pen and protest.

    And like i said, accept the realities, shed your biases, just because Mamata’s bandh one day disrupted your exam does not make the CPM holy. WHOLE STATE wants change. be a part of it.

    And friendship is in its place. In politics, it is immaterial, one FB comment would not be enough to squeeze in all comments. Plus i needed to share all these “facts” about my state with the world hence this blog.


  7. a great job done here agni. i like u to continue this…..this is like a slap to those …….who say ” all iss well”……. even after all this.people look ………………around ..


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: