My Name is Mandira

The title of this post must give you the inkling what’s gonna follow. Yes you guessed it right. I am writing the review of MNIK. But shouldn’t the title have been different then? Well No. That is because the film is watchable because of this one lady whose character is called Mandira in the film.

Kajol steals the show from SRK although she has a minuscule role in the film compared to Khan. The chemistry of the mother and the son is much more enduring than the chemistry that has hit the screens after 8 long years. Yes, people I am also a big fan of the ‘Shajol’ jodi but still I am afraid I can’t sing praises of their sizzling chemistry in this film. There wasn’t much to start with. In fact Mandira agreed to marry Khan because her son Sameer bonded so well with him.

Rizwan Khan, the protagonist, suffers from Asperger’s syndrome, which is a form of autism. He moves in with his brother after his mother’s death. Although mentally “retarted” he is super intelligent, and follows his mother’s advice to the T. He works for his brother as a beauty product salesman and that is how he meets Mandira (at a salon) and falls in love with her.

After their marriage they live happily until the ill-fated 9/11. Post that day, Sameer becomes a victim of racial abuse at school and eventually dies after a racial attack. Mandira for whom her son was her world, loses her calm and asks Rizwan to leave her and come back only after he has told the whole damn world (or at least the POTUS) that His name is Khan and he is not a terrorist.

How Khan does it is infact the film. And it is here that Karan Johar loses it! We all know Karan as a sensible romantic filmmaker. This is his first “serious” venture. And dear me, he has failed. The treatment is cliched. Whole of second half is full of unwanted sub-plots which could have been done away with (like Mama Jenny or the Jignesh segments). The film stretches itself a bit too far and could have been at least 15-20 minutes shorter.

But everything isn’t bad about the movie. For a change, Karan’s movie doesn’t have a song after every 5 minutes. The songs are all used as background score and not lip-synced by the actors. The cinematography is good,s o are the performances. Specially SRK, who has convinced the audience again that he is an actor to reckon with.

The film gives us a message loud and clear. Stereotyping anyone because of his ethnicity or religion is wrong. We should judge a person by his actions. The world is made up of two kinds of people. Good and Bad.

My Rating : 3/5 

About Agnivo Niyogi

Typical Aantel, reader, blogger, news addict, opinionated. Digital media enthusiast. Didi fanboi. Joy Bangla!

Posted on February 16, 2010, in film. Bookmark the permalink. 8 Comments.

  1. Crisp review. I have to agree with you that KJo loses it totally towards the end.


  2. thanx ameen 🙂


  3. hey aagan,Your review is pretty ordinary and the whole idea of Kajol stealing the thunder from SRK is unjustified. You have brought in your prejudice in this review and you sound more like a die hard Kajol fan who simply cannot digest the fact that SRK's role demanded that breathtaking performance that he delivered flawlessly. Trust me, you have no career as a movie critic.Thanks


  4. Exactly. Khan's acting was really ordinary. I was expecting a Swadesh or Chak de like performance from him, but must say he disappointed,as he does often.


  5. @mr anonymous i wrote dis very unbiasedly.u sound like a die hard SRK fan.i just called a spade a spade.SRK cudnt get over his typical mannerisms even while playing autistic sir/mam.


  6. @anonymous i review a movie according to my taste…not to appease a section of the film dont want to become a movie critic to sings praises of average movies


  7. @dibyasundar exactly,Swades is my all time fav from SRK.such flawless and natural performance,but people r so satisfied with mediocirty dat they r impresed by dis ordinary performance


  8. Quite true, Kjo was lost after interval really i'd say.. yup MNIK worth one time watch..but SRK was superb as well.. i aint taking away any credit from him as well.. n i liked this particular line from ur post: My rating : 3/5 (worth a one time watch if the tickets cost less than 80) hahahah!! really nice one..


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: